As a Molson lover…

I’ve got a couple of pet-peeves (don’t we all?) but one of them has become so predominant in our culture that I feel the need to mention it to you, lest you find yourself being interviewed by the press, or speaking to an audience of international diplomats. Please be aware that I’m telling you this knowing that it is nitpicky and specific (as all pet-peeves are), but I bring it to your attention as a public service…and because I love you.

Here it is: I cannot stand “As a….” introductions. When people preface an opinion with a qualifying clause that is meant to lend them irrefutable authority, I immediately discount what they are saying.

Let me give you an example:

as a mom.jpeg

Now read that statement without the “As a Mom.”  It has equal impact, right? The “As a Mom” is meant to add some sort of credential to the speaker, setting her up as an undeniably authoritative (or in this case, sympathetic) voice — but all it really does is make the listener defensive, as if they cannot possibly disagree with the statement without challenging the very notion of this woman’s motherhood!

Do fathers not also get their feelings hurt by teenagers and wish their kids knew that their intentions were good? How about teachers? Grandparents?

Furthermore, it’s obvious from the rest of the statement that the speaker is, in fact, mother to the teenagers in question, which makes it redundant…and you know how we feel about redundancy. (We feel that it’s redundant).

Here’s another example:

Image result for "As a christian..."

Now, there’s a lot wrong with this statement, no matter how you feel about the premise, but we’re going to leave all that alone and focus on the introductory “As a…” phrase, which is the part that’s meant to be inarguable.

Does this mean that if I’m Muslim I can’t agree, or if I’m Christian, I can’t disagree?  Well, yes, because the speaker has staked out an unassailable position of authority on the matter by introducing the statement this way.

[And don’t you get the feeling that if you were to question this person in even the gentlest way about why they feel the way they do, all you’d get is, “Well, I’m a Christian,” meaning, If you were a Christian, you’d understand and agree, but since you don’t, you obviously aren’t?]

You see and hear this all the time these days. “As a man…As a working woman…As a penguin who’s suffered from anal fissures…”  My objection is not at all to people (or penguins) having opinions, but rather to the false rhetorical construct of resting one’s opinions on an introductory clause that is intended to obviate any possible contradictions, or lend some modicum of special authority to what follows.

penguins.jpeg
As fish eaters and hemorrhoid sufferers…

Here’s something I overheard recently:

As a Literature major, I really object to the posthumous release of Harper Lee’s second novel.

What? You object to Go Set a Watchman because you spent your undergrad years writing papers about other people’s books? How does that even make sense?!

You can object because you feel it undermines the social justice statement of To Kill a Mockingbird, or damages Lee’s legacy, or because you suspect there was something unethical in Lee’s lawyer’s “discovery” of the manuscript, or because you read it and it wasn’t good….but how does being a Lit major tell us anything about your objection?

All that statement is meant to do is assert a level of expertise that may or may not exist (and put all you Econ and Bio and History majors in your place. I would suggest you don’t bother challenging anyone who prefaces a statement with “As a Lit major…” because, as a Business major, you couldn’t possibly understand.)

The biologically-related Snarky Assbadger and I like to make a game of “As a…” statements. It’s fun, and we’re easily amused.

oldpeople.jpeg
As someone who prefers peanut butter to colonoscopies, I don’t think octogenarians should be allowed to compete in their own Olympics.
cat.jpeg
As a convicted felon and three-time Grammy nominee, I firmly believe cats should be prevented from knitting at all costs.
enchilada.jpeg
As a self-diagnosed sociopath and Jane Austen lover, I believe enchiladas are the future of the American food industry.
minis.jpeg
As a Spanish-speaking Orthodox Jew who loves macaroons, I find miniature horses both terrifying and distasteful.
salad.jpeg
As a lifelong lesbian and a lineman for the county, I find the idea of salad as a main course slightly preposterous. 

Do you get where I’m going with this?

My point is, if you’ve found yourself adopting this manner of speech, you should understand that — as with the use of the word like or literally — it actually weakens your claim to authority, which is not a plus if you’re intending to persuade someone of something, or establish yourself as an expert.

So you’re much better off deleting this phrase from your rhetorical bag of tricks. Like, literally deleting it.

people.jpeg
As a lactose intolerant seahorse who embraces diversity, I sincerely hope you have a great day!

As a speechwriter, I’m done ranting now…but as a Molson lover, I sincerely think we need to reevaluate the Electoral College.

 

7 thoughts on “As a Molson lover…

  1. As a snarky assbadger, I feel that the indigenous third world counter culture is devoid of righteous indignation.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s